Pulsed vs CW laser cleaning for rust removal
Compare two SFX configurations for rust removal. Start with how much heat the part can tolerate, what finish it needs and how much area you have to clean.
Research byPickaLaserResearch updatedResearch method
Which should you shortlist?
Shortlist pulsed cleaning for parts where preserving the finish or limiting heat is the priority. Quote CW for thick steel and large areas when throughput matters. Ask both sellers to clean the same sample and record the time and finish before committing.
| SFX APC-300 | SFX ALC-1500 | |
|---|---|---|
| Seller configuration | APC-300 IoT | ALC-1500 1500W / air-cooled |
| Rated power | 300 W | 1.5 kW |
| Laser mode | Pulsed | Continuous wave |
| Air cooling | Published for APC-300 | Published for ALC-1500 |
| Sample to send | A finished or thin part with the actual corrosion | A representative area of thick, heavily rusted steel |
| Seller price | $10,027Checked View seller | $5,887Checked View seller |
| Specification source | SFX APC-300 ↗ | SFX ALC-1500 ↗ |
When is the APC-300 worth the higher quote?
Shortlist the pulsed APC-300 if the job calls for selective removal on thin steel, a finished part or a surface that must keep its existing texture. A failed trial on a low-cost coupon can be inexpensive. Rework on an installed part or a damaged production component can cost more than the difference between the machines.
Define the finish before requesting a demo. For example, specify whether the treated part will remain visible or go on to painting. Send a representative part with its actual coating or corrosion, including edges and recesses that need to be cleaned.
When does the ALC-1500 make more sense?
Compare the continuous-wave ALC-1500 for broad areas of thick steel with substantial rust or paint. Ask for the accepted area cleaned during an entire trial, including stops and repeat passes. Divide that area by elapsed time to estimate production capacity on that specific job.
The manufacturer lists 220 V AC input and 5 kW input power for the ALC-1500. Have the seller and your site electrician check the supply, extraction and installation for the exact quoted unit. Include those costs when comparing delivered quotes.
What should a side-by-side trial establish?
Send matched samples from the same job to both sellers. Ask for untreated and treated photos taken under the same lighting, total elapsed time, the area that meets your finish standard and any discoloration, distortion or remaining coating. Request a second run if the first piece varies substantially from production material.
The table reports seller specifications and dated configuration prices. SFX publishes a demonstration of the ALC-1500 on a rusted tank. That demonstration can show the application, but it does not establish comparative throughput, long-term reliability or the finish you will get on your parts.